Probe into learner’s death reveals emotional, homophobic abuse

Share the Article:

Investigative report surrounding the death of a Grade 6 boy learner from Khehlekile Primary School in Tokoza, Ekurhuleni revealed substantial evidence emotional and homophobic abuse.

Sibusiso Mbatha, 12, took his own life on October 23 following alleged incident of bullying he experienced at school.

According to Gauteng department of education, Mbatha was involved in a physical altercation with a fellow learner and that there were instances of comments made and negligence by educators during the aftermath of this altercation.

During a media briefing held by the department on Thursday, investigation revealed substantial evidence supporting allegations of emotional and homophobic abuse by the deputy principal towards Mbatha, contributing to his distress.

“The investigation also noted that the school’s head of department and Mbatha’s class teacher might have mishandled the matter by disregarding proper reporting procedures that could have prevented the incident,” MEC Matome Chiloane said.

Additionally, Chiloane stated that both teachers and the principal were found to have failed in protocol adherence, with the deputy principal’s lack of communication, neglect of reporting procedures, and insensitivity towards the issue.

He added; “The confirmed allegations suggested that the learner’s public reprimand due to their sexual orientation significantly contributed to their distress, highlighting a lack of due process and insensitivity across multiple parties at the school. 

“It was determined that the principal might have failed in fulfilling his responsibilities by mishandling the issue, attempting to shield the deputy and relying solely on written statements from teachers and the head of department.”

The MEC revealed that it is recommended that the head of department and class teacher, due to their alleged flawed handling and failure to follow reporting processes, be charged and undergo disciplinary hearings. 

[WATCH]: Gauteng Education MEC @matomekopano outlined the findings of the investigative report and committed to fulfilling the recommendations made in the report. MEC also spoke about plans to curb the scourge of self-harm at Gauteng schools. pic.twitter.com/koFLBxiUoe

— Gauteng Department of Education (@EducationGP1) November 16, 2023

“The deputy principal is recommended for precautionary suspension and subsequent disciplinary proceedings for alleged ill-treatment, blasphemy, homophobic abuse of the deceased. 

“It is also recommended that the principal must face charges for allegedly neglecting duties, possibly protecting the deputy, and prioritising other stakeholders over the School Governing Body (SGB), along with the reliance solely on written statements”. 

Additionally, trauma counseling for Mbatha’s family, friends, and classmates is strongly recommended to help them cope with the severe trauma they have experienced. 

ALSO READ | Hollywood Foundation to sponsor coaching course in Women’s Football

“We appreciate the findings and recommendations by Rangata Attorneys, and are committed to implement them accordingly.

“Indeed, this should serve as a deterrent for all officials and stakeholders in our school communities.

“No one must feel that their rights are undermined, compromised or disrespected at our schools,” MEC Chiloane concluded.