Broos faces scrutiny over alleged hate speech

Share the Article:

The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) has confirmed that it is assessing hate speech complaints made against Bafana Bafana coach Hugo Broos.

This follows complaints from the United Democratic Movement and the public regarding a recent media briefing by coach Broos, where he made various statements about player Mbekezeli Mbokazi’s transfer to the MLS.

In a complaint lodged with the Commission, Yongama Zigebe, Secretary-General of the United Democratic Movement, requested urgent intervention and investigation into the remarks.

“It is publicly reported that Coach Broos stated of Mr Mbokazi that “he is currently a Black man, but he will come out white after,” allegedly in reference to a missed flight.

“It is further alleged that he referred to Ms Michaels as “that little woman who is his agent who thinks she knows football, if she is a little bit clever …” the letter read.

Zigebe emphasised that if confirmed, these remarks are racially suggestive and sexist, demeaning individuals and undermining the constitutional values governing public institutions, including national sports structures.

He added, “The reported comments, racially coded, derogatory, and gender-diminishing, cannot be dismissed as offhand remarks. They carry historical and cultural significance in a society still healing from the institutionalisation of racism and sexism.

“Public figures, particularly those entrusted with national teams, bear heightened obligations to uphold the values of non-racialism, non-sexism, respect and equality.”

Zigebe highlighted that the complaint is brought not in the spirit of hostility, but out of a firm conviction that our democracy requires vigilance, accountability, and the consistent defence of human dignity.

“Racism and sexism, whether explicit or implied, have no place in our society, and certainly no place within national institutions representing the Republic of South Africa,” he concluded.

Commission evaluating complaint against Broos

In a statement released on Friday, the Commission announced that it has noted views expressed on social media, raising concerns about Broos’ utterances.

“The Commission is currently evaluating the complaint in accordance with the South African Human Rights Commission Act 40 of 2013, together with section 20 of the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act, 2000.

“The Commission emphasised that the right to freedom of expression is not absolute, highlighting that hate speech is prohibited under the Equality Act and the Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Act of 2023.

ALSO READ | Mbokazi sail out of Bucs ship to join Chicago Fire

“Additionally, the Commission recognises the South African Football Association’s contribution in March, during Human Rights Month, in aiding the Commission to disseminate messages promoting anti-racism and a culture of human rights,” the statement read.

SAHRC stated that an update will be made available to members of the public in due course.